The Ongoing Debate: Pastor John MacArthur and Ben Shapiro on Jesus Christ
Exploring Divergent Perspectives on Jesus Between Christianity and Judaism
In a compelling exchange, Pastor John MacArthur once again joins Ben Shapiro on The Ben Shapiro Show to discuss the contentious and profound topic of Jesus Christ. This dialogue revisits themes from their previous interaction four years ago, where Shapiro articulated his Jewish perspective, viewing Jesus as neither divine nor a prophet but a historical figure who led a failed revolt against the Romans. MacArthur, in contrast, seeks to present the Christian understanding of Jesus as the Messiah and divine son of God, emphasizing fulfilled prophecy, eyewitness testimonies, and the transformative power of Christ's resurrection.
Shapiro’s Perspective: Jesus in Jewish Context
Ben Shapiro, a devout Jew, maintains that Jesus was a Jew who lived and died as many others did during Roman rule. He describes Jesus as a man who attempted to lead a rebellion against Roman oppression and was consequently executed. This view aligns with traditional Jewish teachings, which do not recognize Jesus as the Messiah or attribute any divinity to him.
From a Jewish standpoint, Jesus is neither a prophet nor a teacher of great moral authority but rather a figure who, through his followers, became the center of a new religious movement. Shapiro's interpretation suggests that the story of Jesus grew over time, creating a legend that diverged significantly from historical events.
MacArthur’s Argument: Historical and Prophetic Validations
Pastor John MacArthur approaches the discussion with a focus on convincing not only skeptics but specifically addressing Jewish doubts about Jesus. He outlines several key points to support the Christian belief in Jesus' divinity:
1. Fulfilled Prophecy: MacArthur highlights how Old Testament prophecies, which are also part of Jewish scripture, are fulfilled in the New Testament. This continuity, he argues, shows a divine plan that Christians believe culminates in Jesus.
2. Eyewitness Accounts and Miracles: The New Testament is filled with accounts of Jesus performing miracles, witnessed by many. MacArthur emphasizes that these events, documented by multiple sources, add credibility to the Christian narrative.
3. Transformation of the Disciples: MacArthur points to the radical change in Jesus' disciples as evidence of the resurrection. Initially fearful and scattered, these men became bold proclaimers of the Gospel after Jesus’ resurrection, even facing martyrdom for their beliefs.
4. The Unique Character of Jesus: He argues that Jesus' moral teachings and character are uniquely profound and transcendent, suggesting that such a figure could not be the creation of human fabrication or deceit.
Aiming to Bridge the Divide
MacArthur’s goal is not merely to defend Christianity but to bridge the gap between Jewish and Christian interpretations of Jesus by referring extensively to the Old Testament. This shared scripture is a strategic point of connection, as it holds significance for both faiths. MacArthur hopes that by demonstrating how Jesus fulfills Old Testament prophecies, he can encourage Jewish individuals, like Shapiro, to reconsider their views on Jesus.
Confronting Misinterpretations
Shapiro counters by discussing the modern reinterpretations of Jesus in American culture, which he finds problematic. He criticizes the portrayal of Jesus as a figure of nonjudgmentalism and pacifism, arguing that such a depiction is a significant departure from the Jesus of the New Testament, who was often confrontational and judgmental, particularly towards religious hypocrisy.
Shapiro acknowledges that Jesus' crucifixion was not due to his kindness or compassion but because he challenged the religious authorities of his time. This historical context, Shapiro argues, is essential for understanding Jesus' role and the subsequent development of Christian doctrine.
The Challenge of Belief
The conversation takes a more personal turn as MacArthur emphasizes the importance of accepting Jesus as the Messiah. He asserts that without this acceptance, individuals face divine judgment, a point that underscores the fundamental theological divide between Christianity and Judaism. MacArthur elaborates on how Jesus' ministry confronted false religious practices and highlighted the necessity of genuine faith for salvation.
MacArthur's approach, while direct, aims to encourage Shapiro to explore the New Testament and see if the person of Jesus resonates with him as the prophesied Messiah. He suggests that the transformative power of Jesus' life and teachings can only be fully understood through personal engagement with the scriptures.
Practical Differences in Faith and Works
The discussion also touches on the practical differences between Judaism and Christianity regarding faith and works. Shapiro points out that Judaism emphasizes actions leading to faith, where moral behavior fosters a connection with God. In contrast, MacArthur explains that Christianity teaches faith first, followed by actions that reflect one's belief in Jesus. He argues that a truly transformed life, evidenced by moral actions, can serve as a powerful testament to the truth of Christian faith.
A Call to Read the Scriptures
MacArthur’s final plea to Shapiro and to all Jewish people is to read the New Testament and consider its message with an open heart. He believes that the scriptures themselves carry the power to reveal the truth of Jesus as the Messiah. This straightforward approach, devoid of gimmicks or strategies, emphasizes the inherent power of the Gospel to transform lives.
Conclusion: A Dialogue of Faith and Understanding
The ongoing dialogue between Pastor John MacArthur and Ben Shapiro highlights the deep-seated differences in Christian and Jewish interpretations of Jesus. MacArthur's persistent effort to engage Shapiro on this topic reflects a desire to find common ground through shared scriptural references, aiming to foster a deeper understanding and consideration of Jesus' identity.
This discussion is a microcosm of a broader conversation that has been happening for centuries, as Christians and Jews continue to explore their distinct yet interconnected religious heritages. Through respectful dialogue and exploration of these complex theological issues, there is hope for increased mutual understanding and respect between these two faith communities.
Concluding Prayer
In closing, it’s evident that both Shapiro and MacArthur approach this dialogue with deep respect and a genuine desire for understanding. As such, it’s fitting to end with a prayer:
"Heavenly Father, we come before you now boldly. We ask that you just save Ben Shapiro's soul. You've given him an incredible platform to reach many people, and it would just be so joyous if you turn him into a bold warrior for Christ so that he can spread the message of the kingdom of God and save many people from their sins. Bring him that peace and joy and everlasting life. Thank you, Father. Thank you for Ben, and thank you for all that he does. Continue to put more Christians in his life, please, Lord. In Jesus' name, we pray these things. Amen."
Blessings on you and your family, and from all the PLUCare staff! Thank you again for subscribing.
PLUCare is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a paid subscriber. And if you are a paid subscriber, thank you!
I’ve made this post free for all. The biggest help you could give me is to share it widely (I mean, if you enjoyed it that is..)